Beanie Feldstein and Ben Plat.Photo: LISA O’CONNOR/AFP via Getty

Ben PlattandBeanie Feldsteingo way back, and the actor is reminiscing about their years of friendship.
Platt, 27, recounted the way he asked Feldstein, 28, to prom and the special significance it has today during an appearance onThe Tonight Show Starring Jimmy Fallonon Wednesday night.
“We were best friends in high school and we were prom dates and my favorite part about that now is that when I asked her to prom I sent her flowers and I wrote a little card that said … Beanie lovesFunny Girl, which for those who don’t knowshe’s going to star inFunny Girlon Broadway this year, which is wild,” theDear Evan Hansenstar said. “I always knew she lovedFunny Girlso [the card] said, ‘Don’t rain on my parade. Please come to prom with me.’ "
He smiled as he added, “And now she’s Fanny Brice.”
Platt went on to discuss how he and Feldstein each had goals to be cast on Broadway and are now living out their dreams.
“We were big theater nerds together. We starred in all the musicals together in high school and it was always our dream,” the actor toldJimmy Fallon.
In another sweet anecdote about their friendship, Platt shared, “She actually … for my 16th birthday she gave me little cufflinks and she gave me a little note that I have saved that said, ‘Wear these when you win your first Tony.’ and I did. I wore them at Radio City.”
Ben Platt and Beanie Feldstein.ben platt/ instagram

Never miss a story — sign up forPEOPLE’s free daily newsletterto stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.
Feldstein has previously described her relationship with Platt as a “soulmate connection.”
“What I can say is that I think what Ben and I have is beyond friendship, honestly,” she toldBroadway.comlast year. “It’s like a soulmate connection.”
The actress added, “We’re like twins separated at birth or something.”
source: people.com